--- title: The Role of Protected Attributes in AI Fairness description: In this post we’ll explore a few fundamentals to implement fair AI and ML practices for machine learning credit underwriting. image: https://trustscience.com/hubfs/2025%20Brand%20Assets/Blog%20banner%20placeholder.png --- [![Trust Science Logo (Menubar)](https://trustscience.com/hubfs/Trust%20Science%20Logo%20(Menubar).jpg)](https://trustscience.com) - Solutions - [Credit Bureau+™](https://trustscience.com/credit-bureau) - [T°Score™](https://trustscience.com/t-score) - [CashFlow+™](https://trustscience.com/cashflow) - [Services](https://trustscience.com/services) - Industries - [Auto Lenders](https://trustscience.com/auto-lenders) - [Installment & Single Repayment Lenders](https://trustscience.com/installment-single-repayment-models) - Company - [About Us](https://trustscience.com/about) - [Our Team](https://trustscience.com/team) - [Press Releases](https://trustscience.com/blog/tag/press-releases) - [Careers & Culture](https://trustscience.com/careers) - [Patents](https://trustscience.com/technology-patents) - [Resources](https://trustscience.com/resources) - [Marketing Channel Partners](https://trustscience.com/partners) - [News & Blog](https://trustscience.com/blog) - [Events](https://trustscience.com/events) - [Gartner Research](https://trustscience.com/resources/gartner-research-mentions) - Support - [Consumer Disclosure](https://trustscience.com/legal/consumer) - [Consumer Resources](https://trustscience.com/legal/help-page) [CONTACT US](https://trustscience.com/contact) [REQUEST A DEMO](https://trustscience.com/demo) Blog Archive # The Role of Protected Attributes in AI Fairness In this post we’ll explore a few fundamentals to implement fair AI and ML practices for machine learning credit underwriting. [Trust Science](https://trustscience.com/blog/author/trust-science) May 22, 2019 ***Disclaimer**: Thank you for reading. The content you are currently viewing is archived material and may be outdated. We strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, but please be aware that the content in our archives may no longer reflect the latest developments, events, or changes in our field.*  Although there is high corporate demand to leverage the power of artificial intelligence and machine learning, it is critical to provide fairness and mitigate bias when implementing AI and machine learning. In this post we’ll explore a few fundamentals to implement fair AI and ML practices for machine learning credit underwriting. The post can serve as a primer to check against your AI and ML fairness. It is fundamental to implement AI and ML with fairness. Recent coverage of alleged gender-based bias in [Apple’s lending algorithm](https://www.cnn.com/2019/11/10/business/goldman-sachs-apple-card-discrimination/index.html?utm_source=fbCNN&utm_medium=social&utm_content=2019-11-10T22%3A00%3A04&utm_term=link) shows how unfair lending practices can damage a company’s reputation. Ultimately adhering to AI and ML fairness for credit underwriting is good for your business and your customers. You can ensure customers are being serviced correctly which helps your clientele and conversely, your business. And by applying rules for AI and machine learning fairness you can also protect your business against litigation. Consider the following two precedents: 1. [American Express](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/cfpb-and-american-express-reach-resolution-address-discriminatory-card-terms-puerto-rico-and-us-territories/) had to pay a settlement of $96 million for credit discrimination of more than 220,000 of its customers. This was the result of the action taken by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)The auto finance industry has also been fined for discriminatory practices. 2. [American Honda Finance Corp.](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/cfpb-and-doj-reach-resolution-with-honda-to-address-discriminatory-auto-loan-pricing/) and [Ally Bank/Ally Financial](http://money.cnn.com/2013/12/20/news/companies/ally-car-loan-discrimination/index.html) (formerly General Motors Acceptance Corp.) paid a $104 million settlement to African-American, Hispanic, Asian and Pacific Island borrowers for its discriminatory practices. These are only two small examples of the severity companies face when they implement unfair AI and ML practices. It is critical that financial service companies and all credit lenders implement fair lending and also comply with regulations. Financial service companies interested in adopting AI and machine learning to drive automated loan underwriting require full compliance with fair lending laws and regulations. Fair lending laws and regulations in the U.S. include the following: - Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) - Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) - Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act (FACTA) - Fair Housing Act (FHA) - Fair and Equal Housing Act (FEHA) - Consumer Credit Protection Act (CCPA) ## Protected Attributes Lending laws such as the ones mentioned above have a list of anti-discriminatory protected attributes that serve to protect individuals and instill fairness in lending. Attributes are organized by classes. Protected classes under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) include the following: - Age - Color - Marital status (single or married) - National origin - Race - Recipient of public assistance - Religion - Sex Lenders or credit underwriters need to ensure that protected classes of attributes are not being used in machine learning models. Even when these classes of attributes aren’t being used in machine learning models, discrimination may still exist through proxies. Discrimination can be unintentional (disparate impact) or intentional (disparate treatment). ## Unintentional Discrimination (Disparate Impact) Disparate impact is when an individual is discriminated against unintentionally or indirectly. A credit decision that disproportionately affects members within a certain protected class of attributes is disparate impact. Disparate impact can be the result of proxies, in other words, other attributes being used to create biases against protected classes of attributes. For example, regulators do not deem postal codes as a protected attribute and allow them to be used in lending decisioning.  However, a postal code could be a proxy for race or religion and unintentionally discriminate against individuals. ## Intentional Discrimination (Disparate Treatment) Disparate treatment is the intentional discrimination of an individual of a protected class of attributes. For example, if age or race is used directly as a feature in an AI/ML model then the model is considered discriminatory according to ECOA as both age and race are protected attributes. ## **How to Identify Disparate Impact** ##### **The 80% Rule and Statistical Purity** How can you identify disparate impact? Methodologies should not favour any group, however, certain groups may be unintentionally favoured. Statistical purity is a measure of the quality of data categories with neutrality or objectivity. Take color, color is not binary so a statistically pure data sample should reflect a spectrum of colour versus just black and white. To help identify the existence of disparate impact the Pareto Principle or the [80% Rule](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disparate_impact#The_80%_rule) is used. For example, if 650 is considered a prime score, and 80% of an ethnic majority group score above 650 and only 20% of ethnic minority score above 650, then there is discrimination at play according to the 80% rule. The 80% rule is one of the techniques regulators use for testing fairness. ### **ML Models and Fair Lending Regulations** Lastly, if using AI and machine learning, credit underwriters and lenders must provide explainability for  adverse action. This is mandated by various lending laws such as ECOA and FCRA. Clear reasons need to be stated as to why an individual was denied credit, ensuring no discrimination was at play. Fair lending regulations are setting the standards and rules that companies must abide by to limit and reduce potential discriminatory behavior. This is key given the potential for disparate action and disparate treatment. As technology and capabilities like AI and ML integrate into your business, ensure you protect your company and customers by doing the proper due diligence in regulatory compliance. Interested in learning how our Trust Science solution enables AI and ML fairness including explainable AI? [Request a demo](https://trustscience.com/demo). [Blog Archive](https://trustscience.com/blog/tag/blog-archive) ## Similar posts Blog Archive ### [How to Build a Credit Scoring Model – Part 1](https://trustscience.com/blog/how-to-build-a-credit-scoring-model-part-1) At Trust Science, we don’t only use state-of-the-art AI and machine learning algorithms but we take great pride in the variety and types of data we... Trust Science May 6, 2019 Blog Archive ### [Our Bet on Alternative Data for Credit Scoring](https://trustscience.com/blog/our-bet-on-alternative-data-for-credit-scoring) We knew we needed to enable lenders with the means to score any applicant, and give any consumer the ability to get the credit they deserve. Trust Science May 29, 2019 Blog Archive ### [Disrupting Credit Scoring with Credit Bureau 2.0™: Mobile or Nothing](https://trustscience.com/blog/disrupting-credit-scoring-with-credit-bureau-2.0-mobile-or-nothing) In October, as a part of the Money 20/20 show in Las Vegas, Evan Chrapko, CEO & Founder of Trust Science® had the opportunity to speak Trust Science Oct 2, 2018 Trust Science — Footer Redesign [![Trust Science](https://trustscience.com/hubfs/2025%20Brand%20Assets/cropped%20logo.png)](https://trustscience.com) [10130 103 Street, Floor 11  ·  Edmonton, AB Canada T5J 3N9](https://maps.app.goo.gl/59cAdoUxfEKbET3g8) 1(866) 687-8789 #### Solutions - [T°Score™](https://trustscience.com/t-score) - [CashFlow+™](https://trustscience.com/cashflow) - [Credit Bureau+™](https://trustscience.com/credit-bureau) - [Services](https://trustscience.com/services) #### Industries - [Auto Lenders](https://trustscience.com/auto-lenders) - [Installment & Single Repayment Lenders](https://trustscience.com/installment-single-repayment-models) #### Company - [About Us](https://trustscience.com/about) - [Our Team](https://trustscience.com/team) - [Press Releases](https://trustscience.com/blog/tag/press-releases) - [Careers & Culture](https://trustscience.com/careers) - [Technology & Patents](https://trustscience.com/technology-patents) #### Resources - [Marketing Channel Partners](https://trustscience.com/partners) - [News & Blog](https://trustscience.com/blog) - [Events](https://trustscience.com/events) - [Gartner Research](https://trustscience.com/resources/gartner-research-mentions) #### Support - [Client Support](https://trustscience.com/contact-us/) - [Consumer Disclosure](https://trustscience.com/legal/consumer) - [Consumer Resources](https://trustscience.com/legal/help-page) #### Legal - [Privacy Policy](https://trustscience.com/privacy-policy) - [Terms of Use](https://trustscience.com/terms-of-use) - [Data Contribution](https://trustscience.com/data-contribution-policy) - [Smart Consent™](https://trustscience.com/smart-consent) [![SOC 2 Type II — AICPA](https://trustscience.com/hubfs/2025%20Brand%20Assets/aicpa.webp)](https://trustscience.com/news/press-releases/soc2-type2) [![SAP Ariba Verified](https://trustscience.com/hubfs/2025%20Brand%20Assets/arbia.webp)](https://portal.us.bn.cloud.ariba.com/profile/public?anId=AN11173586953&sourceApplication=SBN) Trust Science® is a member of the American Financial Services Association (AFSA), the Canadian Lenders Association (CLA), the National Automotive Finance Association (NAF), The Online Lenders Alliance (OLA) and the Texas Consumer Finance Association (TCFA). Trust Science® is committed to Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance and helping you protect and understand your consumer profile. For more information, please see our [Consumer Disclosure Page](https://trustscience.com/legal/consumer). Trust Science®, Credit Bureau 2.0®, Credit Bureau 3.0® and Troo® are trademarks legally registered to www.TrustScience.com Inc. by the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office. Credit Bureau+™, T°Score™, Six°Score™, CashFlow+™, Smart Consent™, Hidden Prime™, Invisible Prime™, Credit Bureau 4.0™, Personal Credit Bureau™, Personal Data Vault™, Auto Six°Score™, Auto Bureau™, Auto Credit Bureau™, Rating Agency 2.0™, Cashflow Bureau™, One Touch Lending™, Lead to Loan™, Lender in the Cloud™, Flow°Builder™, FCRA-Compliant Insights From Lead to Loan™, Go Beyond the Bureau™, Fixing the Credit Catch-22™, Find Invisible Primes™, and Helping Lenders Find Great Borrowers™ are trademarks of www.TrustScience.com Inc. © 2026 Trust Science Inc. — All rights reserved. ![Trust Science Logo](https://trustscience.com/hs-fs/hubfs/2025%20Brand%20Assets/cropped%20logo.png?width=200&height=36&name=cropped%20logo.png "Trust Science Logo") - [Privacy Policy](https://trustscience.com/privacy-policy) - [Terms of Use](https://trustscience.com/terms-of-use) - [Data Contribution](https://trustscience.com/data-contribution-policy) - [Smart Consent™](https://trustscience.com/smart-consent) - **Solutions** - [T°Score™](https://trustscience.com/t-score) - [CashFlow+™](https://trustscience.com/cashflow) - [Credit Bureau+™](https://trustscience.com/credit-bureau) - [Services](https://trustscience.com/services) - **Industries** - [Auto Lenders](https://trustscience.com/auto-lenders) - [Installment & Single Payment Lenders](https://trustscience.com/installment-single-repayment-models) - **Company** - [About Us](https://trustscience.com/about) - [Our Team](https://trustscience.com/team) - [Press Releases](https://trustscience.com/blog/tag/press-releases) - [Careers & Culture](https://trustscience.com/careers) - [Technology & Patents](https://trustscience.com/technology-patents) - **Resources** - [Marketing Channel Partners](https://trustscience.com/partners) - [News & Blog](https://trustscience.com/blog) - [Events](https://trustscience.com/events) - [Gartner Research](https://trustscience.com/events) - **Support** - [Client Support](https://trustscience.atlassian.net/servicedesk/customer/portal/5/user/login?destination=portal%2F5%2Fgroup%2F13) - [Consumer Disclosure](https://trustscience.com/legal/consumer) - [Consumer Resources](https://trustscience.com/legal/help-page) 10130 103 Street, Floor 11 Edmonton, AB Canada T5J 3N9 1(866) 687-8789 [Follow us on Facebook](https://www.linkedin.com/company/trust-science/?originalSubdomain=ca) [Follow us on Twitter](https://twitter.com/trustscience?lang=ena) [![aicpa](https://trustscience.com/hs-fs/hubfs/2025%20Brand%20Assets/aicpa.webp?width=100&height=99&name=aicpa.webp "aicpa")](https://www.trustscience.com/news/press-releases/soc2-type2) [![arbia](https://trustscience.com/hs-fs/hubfs/2025%20Brand%20Assets/arbia.webp?width=180&height=55&name=arbia.webp "arbia")](https://portal.us.bn.cloud.ariba.com/profile/public?anId=AN11173586953&sourceApplication=SBN) Trust Science® is a member of the American Financial Services Association (AFSA), the Canadian Lenders Association (CLA), the National Automotive Finance Association (NAF), The Online Lenders Alliance (OLA) and the Texas Consumer Finance Association (TCFA).  Trust Science® is committed to Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance and helping you protect and understand your consumer profile. For more information, please see our [Consumer Disclosure Page](https://trustscience-6257140.hs-sites.com/legal/consumer). Trust Science®, Credit Bureau 2.0®, Credit Bureau 3.0® and Troo® are trademarks that are legally registered to www.TrustScience.com Inc. by the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office.  Credit Bureau+™, T°Score™, Six°Score™, CashFlow+™, Smart Consent™, Hidden Prime™, Invisible Prime™, Credit Bureau 4.0™, Personal Credit Bureau™, Personal Data Vault™, Auto Six°Score™, Auto Bureau™, Auto Credit Bureau™, Rating Agency 2.0™, Cashflow Bureau™, One Touch Lending™, Lead to Loan™, Lender in the Cloud™, Flow°Builder™, FCRA-Compliant Insights From Lead to Loan™, Go Beyond the Bureau™, Fixing the Credit Catch-22™, Find Invisible Primes™, and Helping Lenders Find Great Borrowers™ are trademarks of www.TrustScience.com Inc. © 2026 Trust Science Inc. - All rights reserved. ![](https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=7391644&fmt=gif)